RESEAU INTERNATIONAL DES ORGANISMES DE BASSIN
INTERNATIONAL NETWORK OF BASIN ORGANIZATIONS
RED INTERNACIONAL DE ORGANISMOS DE CUENCA


GLOBAL WATER PARTNERSHIP

RESEAU INTERNATIONAL DES ORGANISMES DE BASSIN
GESTION INTEGREE DES RESSOURCES EN EAU
PROGRAMME ASSOCIE :
" CREATION ET RENFORCEMENT DES ORGANISMES DE BASSIN "

 

ANNEXE 5

 

COMPTE RENDU OFFICIEL DE LA REUNION "JUMELAGE" DE LA HAYE
20 Mars 2000

 

 

 

Participants

Copy

Carlos Abihaggle; Joachim Bendow; Dagmara Berbalk; Alain Bernard; Alain Cadiou; Bob Dekker; Jean Francois Donzier; Lisette Enserink; Raymando Garrido; Gene Gibson; Willen Jan Goossen; Janet Herrin; Ron Hoffer; Adriaan Jacobovits de Szeged; Walter Julich; Martinez; Simao Luorino Muhai ; Irene Murphy; A. Oguntola ; Bob Oudshoorn; Jean Louis Prime; Tilak Ranaviraja; Pierre Roussel; Jean François Talec; Rob Uijterlinde; Nigel Walmsley; Roel Zijlmans

attached mailing list

Report of

Reference

Second World Water Forum: preparation twinning arrangements

2000-121

prepared by

Telephone

Bob Oudshoorn

+31-70-311 4437

Date meeting

Annexes

20 March 2000

  1. list of participants and
  2. mailing list / list of interested organisations
  3. reference information on twinning and list of issues which could be included in twinning arrangements
  4. declaration

Opening and scope of the meeting

The Chairperson, Mr Bob Dekker (Head of the International Water Policy Division of Rijkswaterstaat, Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management) welcomed the participants to this meeting (see annex 1). He outlined the scope of the meeting and indicated also that twinning of river basin organisations could be one of the tangible results of this Second World Water Forum. The main aim of the meeting is to investigate if further elaboration of this twinning concept between similar river basin organisations is desirable. If so, the follow up and content of twinning arrangements would be discussed.

Twinning can be an effective tool for accelerating the implementation of integrated water resources management. It may also be beneficial for each of the river basins involved and in particular regarding exchange of information in the field of technical knowledge and expertise, institutional aspects and improvement of management. In the past, good experiences were obtained with similar types of co-operation. Reference material on twinning is included in annex 2 to this meeting report.

The Chairperson highlighted the role of the International Network of River Basin Organisations (INBO; Paris) by the preparations of this twinning concept and this organisation may also facilitate this process. Accordingly, INBO submitted a proposal for a programme to build linkages between existing and new or potential river basin organisations to the Financial Support Group of the Global Water Partnership.

Introduction of the various organisations and their view on the twinning concept.

The participants informed the meeting about their organisations and gave their view on the twinning concept as proposed. In various cases international co-operation takes already place. In particular for "new" organisations, exchange of expertise regarding transfer of technical, institutional and managerial issues is crucial for its development.

The general conclusion was that twinning of river basin organisations could be an effective tool. However, in most cases the regular budgets of the organisations do not provide the possibilities for this type of activities. External financing should be made available via bi-, multilateral co-operation or international financial organisations.

It was indicated that various levels of co-operation are possible. It could vary between a simple exchange of documents and a concrete close co-operation and support on the relevant issues, but should be based on the needs and demands of the respective organisations. The use of the same working languages facilitates the co-operation.

It was concluded that the content of these arrangements should be customised upon the wishes, needs and possibilities of the organisations involved and are dependent of the availability of resources. A not exhaustive list of issues that could be included in twinning arrangements is included in appendix 1 to annex 2 to this report.

The Chairperson concluded that there is a clear need for international co-operation between river basin organisations. The draft declaration as was prepared by the Netherlands could be a basis for the future activities.

Follow up

The participants gave also their view on the outline of the draft declaration that was prepared by the Netherlands. After discussion and amending, several organisations indicated that they were willing to undersign the revised declaration.

Closure of the meeting

Under the patronage of the Netherlands Vice Minister of Transport, Public Works and Water Management, Mrs. Monique de Vries, the following organisations undersigned the declaration of intent (annex 3): Lake Chad Basin Commission; Zambesi Valley Development Authority; Agence de l’Eau Loire Bretagne; Agence de l’Eau Adour Garonne; Agence de l’Eau Rhône Méditerranée Corse; International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River; International Commission for the Protection of the Rhine; and Departemento General de Irrigacion, Gobierno de Mendoza.

 

 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION Annex 2

Twinning of river basin organisations

Introduction

It is nowadays generally recognised that water management at river basin level is a crucial element for obtaining sustainable development. All aspects which might influence the quality and quantity of the water, both surface water and groundwater, need to be addressed in an integrated approach. Many international conventions, agreements and arrangements elaborate on river basin management.

International declarations further clearly underline the need for action, sharing knowledge and experience, preparation of case studies of co-operative management programmes and support for transfer of experience (clearing house mechanism). A good tool for meeting those needs is twinning of river basin organisations.

Twinning

Twinning is a well-known concept for the exchange of knowledge and experience between two organisations. Twinning has been successfully applied in many circumstances. In the case of twinning between river basin organisations it means that two river basin organisations have a structural relationship, in which the exchange of knowledge and experience is a crucial element.

Potential twinning partners

These river basin organisations should preferably have more or less comparable type of problems, either geographically and/or administratively. The emphasis should be put on coupling river basin organisations from regions in different stages of development. Meanwhile, the learning and experience-sharing process is meant to be mutual, and not one-sided.

Twinning arrangement

The actual activities to be carried out under a twinning relationship are based on the needs, wishes and possibilities of the two river basin organisations, and may change in the course of time. Main elements for the exchange of knowledge and experience and co-operation could be: capacity building, the development of legal, institutional, administrative and planning frameworks, instruments, monitoring, data-handling and assessment.

As soon as agreement is reached, for instance by the signing of a letter of intent between the two organisations, deliberations about the exact content of a twinning arrangement could start. Apart from describing the type of information which will be exchanged, information about the definition and purpose, procedure for further elaboration and development, technical issues about the co-operation, time-frame and follow-up, and budgets / sponsors should be included.

An overview of potential elements for a twinning arrangement is attached in appendix 1. This list is neither exhaustive, nor should all elements necessarily be included in the agreement.

2nd WWF & MC

By autumn 1999 the Netherlands, host of the 2nd WWF and the Ministerial Conference, has addressed letters to about twenty of the worlds largest river basin organisations, asking them if they would be interested in twinning with other river basin organisations. The positive reactions have stimulated the Netherlands in the further elaboration of this concept. An overview of the organisations having reacted positive until so far is given in appendix 2.

 

It is recognised that a twinning arrangement will involve costs. The extent of the costs depends on the content of the twinning arrangement, but anyhow costs for travelling, subsistence and for translation of documents will have to be made. Some countries have indicated that they have already set aside a budget to contribute to this new and promising form of twinning.

 

 

 

 

Appendix 1

Possible elements in twinning arrangements

This list should be regarded upon as a shopping list of possible elements and is based on an analysis of a number of Memoranda of Understanding regarding international co-operation. This list is neither exhaustive, nor should all elements necessarily be included in twinning arrangements and agreements.

  1. description and purpose
    1. description of the respective organisations
    2. purpose of the agreement
    3. areas of special mutual interest.
  2. procedure for the further elaboration of the Twinning Agreement
    1. designation of contact persons
    2. exchange of relevant documents and reports
    3. frequency of visits (at least bi-annual) and contacts
    4. participation at the meetings
    5. training on the job / scholarship
    6. organisation of workshops
    7. general consultation
    8. opening of web sites
    9. exchange programs of experts
    10. employment of experts
    11. reporting and evaluation of the activities in this framework
  3. Issues
    1. water quality
    1. water quality
    1. ecology (water quality and quantity)

 

    1. integrated approach / implementation
    1. socio-economical aspects and finances
    1. transboundary effects of the co-operation
    1. co-operation between the partners
    1. legal, administrative an institutional framework
    2. management of the organisations
  1. period and follow up
    1. the agreement is valid for a limited time period of 3/4/5 years.
    2. the activities within this framework should be assessed regularly.
  2. finances / sponsors
    1. information about the financing of the twinning activities
    2. reporting back to the sponsors about the activities and the progress made
    3. sharing expenses: travel, hotel accommodation, etc.
  3. co-operation with other international organisations
    1. where appropriate specific attention could be paid to general international organisations
    2. participation of other connected organisations

 

DECLARATION OF INTENT ON THE FORMATION OF TWINNING ARRANGEMENTS

BETWEEN RIVER BASIN ORGANISATIONS

 

 

We, representatives of river basin organisations,

took note of many international declarations and policy papers indicating that integrated water resource management at river basin level is a crucial element for obtaining sustainable development (for example : Dublin 1992, chapter 18 AGENDA 21 Rio de Janeiro 1992, Rio + 5 1997, CSD 6 1998, Petersberg 1998, Paris 1998). In those declarations statements as "need for action", "sharing knowledge and experience, preparation of case studies of co-operative management programmes and support for transfer of experience (clearing house mechanism) are often included.

took note of the discussions at the Second World Water Forum on integrated water resource management in river basins,

recognised that river basin organisations, situated in different parts of the world, have developed broad experience, and that exchange of information between these organisations on their experiences can strengthen their institutions, their functioning and their effectiveness,

recognised that twinning arrangements between river basin organisations can be an effective tool for accelerating the implementation of integrated water resource management and solving water problems,

agree to take the necessary steps, conditional to the availability of adequate resources, to seek to enter into suitable twinning arrangements.

 

 

THE HAGUE, 20 March 2000

 

 

 

It concerns the following institutions and contact persons:

representative

institute / organisation

address

ZIP code

city

country

telephone

fax

e mail

1

A.

Oguntola

Lake Chad Basin Commission

PO box 727

Ndjamena

2

Simao Luorino

Muhai

Director GPZ; Zambesi Valley Development Authority; Rua da Resistencia 1746

Rua Da Resistencia N. 1746

Bloco B; 9 Andar MAPUTO

9

ANDAR MAPUTO

MOZAMBIQUE

+258-1-41 7650 /

+258-1-418 175

+258-1-418 170

gaplaza@zebra.uem.net

3

Jean François

Talec

Agence de l’Eau Loire Bretagne

Avenue de Buffon; BP 6339

45063

ORLEANS CEDEX 02

FRANCE

+33 2 38 51 73 73

++33 2 38 51 7427

jean-françois.talec@eau-loire-bretagne.fr

4

Martinez

Agence de l’Eau Adour Garonne

90, rue du Férétra

31708

TOULOUSE CEDEX 04

FRANCE

+ 33 5 61 36 37 38

direct: + 33-56136 3752

+ 33 5 61 36 37 28

e mail:

5

Pierre

Roussel

Agence de l’Eau Rhône Méditerranée Corse

2-4 Allee de Lodz

69363

LYON CEDEX 09

FRANCE

+ 33 4 72 71 2600

++ 33 4 72 71 2601

pierre.roussel@environnement.gouv.fr

6

Joachim

Bendow

International Commission for the Protection of the Danube RiverVienna International Center DO 443

PO Box 500

1400

VIENNA

AUSTRIA

+ 43 1 260 60 5730

+ 43 1 260 60 5895

icpdr@unvienna.org

7

Adriaan

Jocobovits de Szeged

International Commission for the Protection of the RhineHohenzollernstrasse 18

PO Box 309

56068

KOBLENZ

GERMANY

+ 49 261 124 95

+ 49 261 365 72

iksr@rz-online.de

8

Carlos

Abihaggle

Departemento General de Irrigacion, Gobierno de Mendoza

Av. Espana y Barcala

5500

MENDOZA

ARGENTINA

+ 54 261 420 2674

+ 54 261 420 5455

cabihag@irrigacion-mendoza.gov.ar

 

 

SOMMAIRE